[Retracted] Security and Makespan Trade-Off Strategy in Fog-Enabled IoT Networks

<div>Comparison between the proposed algorithm and the random one. (a) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M394" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (b) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M395" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M384 0V27C293 34 287 42 287 114V635C232 613 172 594 109 583V559L157 557C201 555 205 550 205 499V114C205 42 199 34 109 27V0H384Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (c) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M396" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M397" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M285 378C315 398 338 416 353 432C373 451 384 474 384 503C384 579 325 635 236 635H235C182 635 136 610 108 579L65 516L85 496C110 533 150 575 205 575C258 575 300 543 300 481C300 407 232 369 141 339L147 310C163 315 188 321 211 321C268 321 338 284 338 192C338 94 288 40 217 40C160 40 119 68 93 91C85 98 77 97 69 91C60 84 47 71 46 58C44 46 48 35 62 22C75 10 116 -12 162 -12C234 -12 424 62 424 224C424 297 373 359 285 376V378Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (d) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M398" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M456 178V225H360V632H320C217 496 115 347 20 206V178H280V106C280 40 276 34 189 27V0H445V27C364 34 360 39 360 106V178H456ZM280 225H82C149 335 214 431 278 520H280V225Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span> (e) <span class="nowrap"><svg height="9.25986pt" id="M399" style="vertical-align:-0.2455397pt" version="1.1" viewbox="-0.0498162 -9.01432 53.0861 9.25986" width="53.0861pt" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,0,0)"><path d="M714 664L702 678C677 661 651 638 627 626C588 607 568 607 547 607C524 607 496 619 461 638C391 673 360 687 319 687C215 687 144 611 144 536S191 410 271 410C339 410 379 452 412 517L394 526C361 473 326 440 273 440C209 440 185 482 185 534S237 635 301 635C329 635 366 621 403 601C456 572 487 557 527 557C532 557 540 557 547 558C427 454 384 369 336 292C189 231 53 149 53 45C53 9 77 -15 110 -15C127 -15 146 -11 166 -4C260 31 369 152 443 298L550 339C495 254 446 155 446 77C446 21 481 -12 533 -12C594 -12 659 42 735 134L714 147C642 63 586 18 547 18C528 18 513 32 513 53C513 111 593 253 687 387C835 446 991 527 991 637C991 673 965 687 934 687C874 687 752 597 612 422L579 379C540 364 503 356 464 340C536 484 606 581 696 650L714 664ZM958 635C958 559 851 493 720 434C805 554 896 657 934 657C950 657 958 650 958 635ZM307 241C253 147 171 15 110 15C98 18 86 24 86 44C86 120 179 182 307 241Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,16.593,0)"><path d="M535 323V373H52V323H535ZM535 138V188H52V138H535Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,27.856,0)"><path d="M412 140C382 77 369 73 315 73H129L270 222C362 320 402 379 402 466C402 571 322 635 234 635C177 635 130 609 99 576L42 495L64 475C90 514 133 568 201 568C274 568 318 519 318 435C318 349 255 267 193 193C144 135 87 78 32 23V0H405C417 45 427 89 440 131L412 140Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,34.096,0)"><path d="M153 550H386L412 615L406 623H120L82 318C104 327 142 338 184 338C294 338 347 275 347 187C347 112 305 39 221 39C160 39 119 71 97 89C88 97 80 96 71 90C59 80 50 67 49 57C48 45 52 36 66 23C80 9 123 -12 169 -12C221 -11 288 15 342 59C403 109 431 165 431 225C431 308 366 395 238 395C212 395 165 379 127 364L153 550Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,40.336,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g><g transform="matrix(.013,0,0,-0.013,46.576,0)"><path d="M241 635C89 635 35 457 35 312C35 153 89 -12 240 -12C390 -12 443 166 443 312C443 466 390 635 241 635ZM238 602C329 602 354 454 354 312C354 172 330 22 240 22C152 22 124 173 124 313S148 602 238 602Z"></path></g></svg>.</span></div>

Security and Communication Networks

fig7

Figure 7

Figure 7: [Retracted] Security and Makespan Trade-Off Strategy in Fog-Enabled IoT Networks 