Research Article

A Fault Diagnosis Method for One-Dimensional Vibration Signal Based on Multiresolution tlsDMD and Approximate Entropy

Table 1

Fault diagnosis methods and performance for NASA and CWRU signals based on SVM and ANN.

Ref.Main featuresDatabase, bearing statesClassifierAccuracy (%), state samples

[61]EMD energy entropy of the first eight IMFsNASA, sevenANN93. Total 5394 records divided into five folds, training: Four folds, test: one fold
[62]Time and frequency domain featuresNASA, sevenLinear SVM and quadratic SVM99.4 of linear SVM, 99.3 of quadratic SVM. Training: 80%, test: 20%
[63]Time domain featuresNASA, twoClassical SVM (CSVM), incremental SVM (ISVM)Outer: 91.1 CSVM and 98.7 ISVM, inner: 92.0 CSVM and 94.5 ISVM. Training: 70, test: 30
[64]FFTNASA, two1D convolutional neural networks (1D CNN)97.1 of 1D CNN, 94.5 of FFT-SVM
[65]LMD, sample entropy, and energy ratioCWRU, fourSVM100. Training: 60, test: 20
[66]Time and frequency, EMD energy entropyCWRU, evenAdaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS)94.7 (average). Training: 140, test: 70
[67]DWT (cluster-based feature extraction)CWRU, tenProbabilistic neural network98.2 (maximum). Training: 168, test: 60
[68]EMD sample entropy of the first ten IMFsCWRU, sixImproved shuffled frog leaping algorithm (ISFLA)100 for H, others 95.4 (maximum). Training: 140, test: 70
[69]LMD-SVDCWRU, tenBPNN SVM, extreme learning machine (ELM)97.7 (average) for BP, 98.8 (average) for SVM, 99.3 (average) for ELM. Test: 228
[70]Continuous wavelet transform (CWT)CWRU, tenConvolutional neural network (CNN)99.7 of CNN, 99.7 of CNN, 85.1 of BPNN training: 200, Test: 200
[71]Transfer learningCWRU, sixNeural networks91.8 (total). Total: 4832, training: 1208
[72]Time domain featuresCWRU, tenHierarchical adaptive deep CNN (ADCNN)99.7 (average). Training: 500, test: 500
[73]SVD, the singular valuesCWRU, fourANN95.1, training: 336, test: 144