Research Article

An Improved Effective Cost Review Process for Value Engineering

Table 2

Form/structure checklist and representative cases.

CategorySubcategoryRepresentative cases

Form/structureSimplification Idea stimulus question: 
Can a part of the form or structure be simplified?
 Complex gasket (to flat one)
 Friction holder rear_comb pattern ribs (to simple pattern ribs)
 Belt carrier_whole sawtooth (to partial sawtooth)
 Speech circuit design_primary, speech IC and two relay (to secondary, OP Amp and one relay)
Elimination Idea stimulus question:  
Can a part of the form/structure be eliminated?
 Cover duct_PE foam sheet
 Fan motor transistor_Heat sink
 Paper feeder_Center area
 Wire harness of speaker assembly_EMI core
 Back up battery for power failure_lithium battery
 Main-NCU_cable tie
 Operating and Main PBA_shrink tube
CombinationIdea stimulus question:
Can a part of the form or structure be combined?
 Fan and box (to one piece)
 Cover_side part and top part (to one piece)
 Guide and auto document feeder (to one piece)
 Facsimile machine_rear and top cover (to one piece)
 Operating voltage_5.0 and 3.3 volts (to 3.3 volts)
RearrangementIdea stimulus question: 
Can a part of the form or structure be rearranged?
 The main PBA_primary component (to optional PBA)
 PCB bottom_wire harness (to the side of the frame using pattern)
 TRIAC_bottom heat sink (to the path of the air ventilation)
 Handset Curl cord_Modular jack (to handset PBA)
Unused EliminationIdea stimulus question:  
Can an unused part of the form or structure be eliminated?
 Relay_unused contacts
 Hinge low guide_unused pin
 Variable resistor_unused range