Journal of Nursing Management / 2024 / Article / Tab 3 / Review Article
Systematic Review and Psychometric Properties Analysis of First-, Middle-, and Top-Level Nurse Manager’s Core Competencies Instruments Table 3 The methodological quality of psychometric properties and level of evidence of included studies.
Authors (no . of reference) Relevance Comprehensiveness Comprehensibility Overall content validity Structural validity Internal consistency Reliability Construct validity Recommendation Wang et al., 2022 [22 ] −/M −/M +/M +/M −/M +/M ?/M B Collins et al., 2017 [23 ] +/M +/M +/M ?/M −/L ?/L B Chase, 2010 [5 ] +/M +/M +/M +/M −/M +/M +/M +/M B Donaher et al., 2007 [24 ] +/L −/L ?/L −/L −/L +/L +/L B Gunawan et al., 2019 [25 ] +/M +/M +/M +/M −/M +/M A DeOnna, 2006 [26 ] +/M +/M +/M +/M −/L +/L +/L A Moghaddam et al., 2019 [27 ] +/M +/M +/M +/M +/L +/L A Tongmuangtunyatep et al., 2015 [28 ] +/H +/H +/H +/H +/H +/H +/H A Shuman et al., 2017 [29 ] +/M +/M +/M +/M ?/M +/M A Rosenfeld et al., 2012 [30 ] −/M +/M +/M +/M −/VL ?/VL +/VL B
Methodological quality of the study measurement properties was rated as follows: + = sufficient; − = insufficient; and ? = indeterminate. Quality of evidence was rated as follows: H = high; M = moderate; L = low; and VL = very low.